By Paisley Livingston

The more and more renowned concept that cinematic fictions can "do" philosophy increases a few tough questions. who's really doing the philosophizing? Is it the philosophical commentator who reads common arguments or theories into the tales conveyed via a movie? may well or not it's the filmmaker, or a bunch of taking part filmmakers, who increase and take a look at to reply to philosophical questions with a movie? Is there anything in regards to the event of flicks that's in particular fitted to the stimulation of valuable philosophical reflections? within the first a part of this publication, Paisley Livingston surveys positions and arguments surrounding the cinema's philosophical price. He increases criticisms of daring theses during this quarter and defends a reasonable view of film's attainable contributions to philosophy. within the moment a part of the e-book he defends an intentionalist strategy that makes a speciality of the filmmakers' philosophical history assumptions, resources, and goals. Livingston outlines intentionalist interpretative ideas in addition to an account of authorship in cinema. The 3rd a part of the booklet exemplifies this intentionalist process with regards to the paintings of Ingmar Bergman. Livingston explores the relationship among Bergman's paintings and the Swedish director's basic philosophical source--a treatise in philosophical psychology authored by way of the Finnish thinker, Eino Kaila. Bergman proclaimed that analyzing this booklet used to be a massive philosophical adventure for him and that he "built in this ground." as regards to fabrics within the newly created Ingmar Bergman archive, Livingston exhibits how Bergman took up Kaila's subject matters in his cinematic explorations of stimulated irrationality, inauthenticity, and the matter of self-knowledge.

Show description

Read or Download Cinema, Philosophy, Bergman: On Film as Philosophy PDF

Best Film books

Parallel Lines: Post-9/11 American Cinema

Parallel traces describes how post-9/11 cinema, from Spike Lee's twenty fifth Hour (2002) to Kathryn Bigelow's 0 darkish Thirty (2012), pertains to varied, and competing, models people nationwide identification within the aftermath of the September eleven terrorist assaults. The ebook combines readings of person motion pictures (World alternate heart, United ninety three, Fahrenheit Sept. 11, free swap) and cycles of flicks (depicting revenge, conspiracy, torture and warfare) with prolonged remark on ordinary subject matters, together with the connection among the united states and the remainder of the realm, narratives of healing restoration, questions of moral legal responsibility.

Godard: Images, Sounds, Politics (BFI Cinema)

Godard: photographs, Sounds, Politics is a crucial step in making experiments in photograph and sound past the associations of cinema and tv obvious. It reads the sooner motion pictures during the more moderen paintings, targeting politics, expertise and sexuality. those insistent topics dominate Godard's research of our illustration within the picture, a illustration consistently inflected by means of sound.

Black Space: Imagining Race in Science Fiction Film

Winner, Rollins publication Award, Southwest Texas pop culture Association/American tradition organization, 2008Science fiction movie deals its audience many pleasures, now not least of that is the potential for imagining different worlds within which very assorted types of society exist. no longer unusually, despite the fact that, those substitute worlds frequently turn into areas during which filmmakers and picture audiences can discover problems with obstacle in our personal society.

The Richard Burton Diaries

Irresistibly magnetic on degree, captivating in video clips, seven instances an Academy Award nominee, Richard Burton rose from humble beginnings in Wales to turn into Hollywood's such a lot hugely paid actor and one among England's such a lot popular Shakespearean performers. His epic romance with Elizabeth Taylor, his mythical ingesting and story-telling, his mind-blowing purchases (enormous diamonds, a jet, houses on numerous continents), and his huge, immense expertise saved him consistently within the public eye.

Additional info for Cinema, Philosophy, Bergman: On Film as Philosophy

Show sample text content

Sixteen. determine 1. 17. 31 32 Surveying Cinema as Philosophy determine 1. 18. Counter-revolutionary magic in October. determine 1. 19. Theses on Cinema as Philosophy 33 aspect of such intercutting may be to distinction Christian and different varieties of statuary as they're evidently multiple in lots of methods. If the montage series by itself provides the viewers solid cause to think whatever, it's that the director had made a few form of particularly imprecise comparability among Russian orthodox Christianity and different religions, in addition to the blunt concept that faith is counter-revolutionary. ponder, for instance, the subsequent assertion of goal that looks a couple of pages later within the essay via Eisenstein that Smuts cites: An instance of this [intellectual overtone] are available within the series of the ‘gods’ in October, the place the entire stipulations for his or her comparability are made depending on an completely class-intellectual sound of every piece in its relation to God. I say classification, for notwithstanding the emotional precept is universally human, the highbrow precept is profoundly tinged through classification. those items have been assembled in keeping with a descending highbrow scale—pulling again the concept that of God to its origins, forcing the spectator to understand this ‘progress’ intellectually. ¹⁶ What, within the context of the film of which it's a half, does the montage series point out concerning the starting place of the idea that of God? And, extra pointedly, what does it ‘force’ the spectator to imagine? little or no. it truly is worthy mentioning that lots of my Hong Kong scholars file at the foundation of a first viewing of the film that they find the montage series hugely perplexing. They ask yourself, for instance, why similar to a statue of Buddha figures the place it does within the montage. Are the pictures which are linked to a counter-revolutionary Christianity contrasted negatively to pictures linked to extra peaceable and enlightened religions? Spectators who, not like those scholars, have the needful history wisdom touching on Eisenstein’s highbrow heritage and said intentions may possibly comprehend the series as a extra specific assault on Christianity as a sort of repressive ideology ‘just like different religions’, together with those who are ‘lower’ on a few tendentious ‘intellectual scale’. they could additionally then comprehend the visible rhetoric as expressing Hegel-inspired prejudices approximately sculpture and the lowly position of African and Asian artwork inside of world-historical improvement. whatever like this turns out to notify Eisenstein’s above-quoted comment approximately how the later photographs within the series disagree with ‘our suggestion of God’ and its relation to deities on a ‘lower highbrow scale’, the place the first-person-plural pronoun most likely used to be intended to consult Russians or non-Asians. ¹⁶ Eisenstein, ‘Methods of Montage’, eighty two. 34 Surveying Cinema as Philosophy whereas the instance of Eisenstein’s ‘intellectual montage’ reinforces the concept film-maker can use the cinematic medium in addition to different skill to induce a few primary Marxist aspect (all faith is the ‘opiate of the masses’), it not often helps the daring declare that film has a distinct skill independently to precise significant and cutting edge philosophical reasoning, akin to a brand new thesis concerning the beginning of the idea that of God.

Rated 4.49 of 5 – based on 8 votes